
F1 | Mercedes engine sparks debate again: FIA considers ways to avoid immediate protests
Even after the Barcelona F1 tests, Mercedes has impressed with its performance. The FIA is now considering ways to prevent other teams from lodging immediate complaints about the engine.
After the Barcelona tests, Mercedes confirmed its status as the team to watch. Completing the highest number of laps without incidents, the team demonstrated the exceptional reliability of their power unit, which has already been the subject of intense debate. The FIA is now looking for compromises to prevent protests from rival teams.
Early signals from Barcelona
Although the Barcelona tests were not fully indicative of overall performance, they provided encouraging insights regarding reliability. The leading engine manufacturers managed to cover significant mileage, alleviating fears of structural issues.
Mercedes, running three teams, completed 1,134 laps, while Ferrari, also with three teams, recorded 991 laps. Red Bull Powertrains Ford collected data over 624 laps. In contrast, the two newcomers, Audi and Honda, faced more difficulties.
The compression ratio controversy and the risk of protests
Even after these early signals on track, engine-related issues remain one of the most delicate topics as the new regulatory cycle begins. At the center of the debate is the compression ratio of the Mercedes power unit.
Nikolas Tombazis, FIA technical director for the single-seaters, clarified the Federation’s position: “We absolutely do not want the championship to start with people interpreting the regulations in slightly different ways.”
“I think it’s fair to say there are areas where the rules are not entirely clear to everyone. The main objective is to ensure that the issue is resolved definitively before the first race, so that no further discussions arise. We are still working on what the solution might be.”
Mercedes’ potential technical advantage and possible solutions
The estimated advantage for Mercedes is around two tenths of a second. The FIA has already given preliminary approval to a potential solution, but other engine manufacturers are seeking formal guarantees on full legality under all operating conditions.
As reported by Motorsport.com Italy, several proposals have been considered to avoid dissatisfaction and protests from Melbourne onwards, but all are complex to implement.
The main proposal would allow an adjustment to the internal combustion engine to reduce the gap to Mercedes before the power checks scheduled by the ADUO at the sixth Grand Prix, potentially even outside the spending constraints.
An alternative could be to limit the energy flow of the Petronas fuel supplied to Mercedes, echoing the 2019 precedent with the introduction of the second FIA flow meter, though without precise data to measure any advantage. A third proposal would require Brixworth to self-certify, formally committing to declare the power unit fully compliant under all conditions of use.
The tension surrounding Mercedes’ compression ratio highlights the fragile political balance of the 2026 regulations, where a two-tenth advantage could trigger a legal standoff before the first green flag drops in Melbourne. By proactively seeking a compromise, Nikolas Tombazis and the FIA are attempting to shield the sport from the “war of interpretations” that has historically marred the introduction of radical technical changes. Whether the solution involves allowing rival manufacturers a free hand to upgrade their internal combustion engines or imposing strict fuel constraints on Petronas, the goal remains clear: ensuring the 2026 era begins as a battle of drivers on track rather than lawyers in a courtroom. As the clock ticks down to the Australian Grand Prix, the transparency of the Brixworth factory’s self-certification may be the final hurdle in maintaining a unified and competitive grid for this high-stakes new chapter of Formula 1.



Leave a Reply